
For years, Rep. Paul Ryan (R-Wis.), the right-wing chairman of the House Budget Committee, has been widely described as an Ayn Rand acolyte, best known for assigning "Atlas Shrugged" to members of his staff. Now, however, the Republican lawmaker finds humor in his reputation.
"You know you've arrived in politics when you have an urban legend about you, and this one is mine," Ryan chuckled in an interview with National Review. He added, "I reject her philosophy. It's an atheist philosophy." Ryan said he prefers Thomas Aquinas, concluding, "Don't give me Ayn Rand."
I'll gladly assume the man is familiar with his own philosophy, but it's curious to see him distance himself from Rand in this way, especially in light of his apparent preoccupation with her vision. As Alex Pareene noted, Ryan is, after all, the same guy who made these comments:
"The reason I got involved in public service, by and large, if I had to credit one thinker, one person, it would be Ayn Rand." [...]
"I give out 'Atlas Shrugged' as Christmas presents, and I make all my interns read it. Well ... I try to make my interns read it."
National Review knocked Ryan's detractors for making "Rand-related slams," but is it a "slam" to take Ryan's own words about the author at face value? For that matter, is it really unreasonable to note that Ryan's radical budget plan, which redistributes wealth from the bottom up, seems to have been inspired, at least in part, by a Rand-like philosophy?
Incidentally, Ryan also spoke at some length at Georgetown yesterday about his governing philosophy, which featured a defense of sorts against the criticisms he'd received from leaders of his own Roman Catholic church. As Ed Kilgore reported, the Wisconsinite "mainly relied on the argument that the 'fiscal crisis' facing the country trumped any concern over his budget's impact on the poor and vulnerable."
It seems like the kind of attitude Ayn Rand would approve of.
Regardless, in case anyone's forgotten, there is no debt crisis. The United States can easily borrow as much as it needs at low interest rates, suggesting there's nothing even close to a debt crisis. This is a fig leaf Ryan and the right is using to rationalize draconian cuts to domestic priorities, which they've long wanted to make anyway.
Second, if Ryan and his allies were seriously panicked about reducing the deficit and getting our fiscal house in order, they'd consider modest tax increases on the wealthy. Indeed, we know exactly what's driving the national debt, and much of it has to do with tax cuts the rich didn't need and the country couldn't afford. When Ryan acknowledges this, he'll start to have some credibility on the issue.
And third, for all of Ryan's alleged fear about the debt, his last budget plan ignored deficit reduction altogether, and instead prioritized more tax breaks for those at the very top. Asked yesterday about tax loopholes he'd be willing to close to help pay for his plans, Ryan refused to go into any detail.
Update: Our pal James Carter passes along this remarkable clip of Rand gushing about Rand in 2009 -- not exactly ancient history -- and how relevant he considers her work in his attacks on Democrats and the modern welfare state.





Ayn Rand’s novel , The Romantic Manifesto, is a story of the death of hope and the human spirit, in communist Russia. She was an idealist. Ideally if everyone was morally prefect, we would not need police, armies or taxes. The valuing of the individual, over the group, is not new. Common sense is still the rarest of ideals. As children, we up hold individualism. As businessmen ,we want to believe we did it all by ourselves. The true GDP of human worth can be measured by the love one feels for ones mother.
so if somethign is true, how is it an "urban legend"? Is Mr. Ryan, a "good Christian" lying again. And I do love how he's only offended by Rand becasue she was "gasp" an atheist. Just goes to show that atheists can be heartless idiots too, just like him.
and pondering-2, Rand does not describe "morally perfect", if there were such a thing. She wants a world where everyone is like what she'd wnated to be, and even she failed dramatically in that. She is only an "idealist" in that she wants her "ideal" only. There is no "common sense" in being a greedy vain person.
Greed and hording is evidence of moral corruption. Idealism, optional.
Ayn Rand may have been many things, but a Republican like flip-flopper was not one of them. As a Democrat, I believe I should care for humanity as I would any loved one. The Young Republicans / Objectivist often used emergency survival situations like, ten shipwrecked souls fighting over a four person row boat. Not a situation to write a philosophy from. What if I could not be happy with myself if I survived at the expense of another ? Would I be sacrificing my ideals if I swam away, and very possibly drown, rather then survive at another’s expense ?? Their answer was, push your ma out of the boat. That’s her problem. Maybe she is a real good swimmer ? Wow. . . . These kids may not have been breast fed as babies, or something ? How can one maintain self-respect, while trampling all possibilities of fairness ??
Maybe Mitt Romney loaned his Etch-A-Stech to Ryan ?
Has one of the Republican constituent finally caught up on who Ayn Rand is and start asking him in one of his paid town hall meeting: "Hey....I heard Ayn Rand is an atheist.....what's up with that?"
The Catholic Church must be polling better than Ayn Rand right now.
As an adopted descendant of the Ryan clan, I call out this idiot as a traitor to his own Ryan ancestors, who came to the USA as poor Irishmen fleeing the poverty caused by greedy plutocratic "capitalist" oppressors. He is nothing more than the equivalent of the puppet Irish traitors who exploited their own people at the behest of their British benefactors over a century ago. He has spit on the graves of those who gave him his name.
NEVER TRUST ANYONE WHO BELIEVES AYN RAND !!!
Did he just find out Ayn Rand's views on abortion? She said,
"An embryo has no rights. Rights do not pertain to a potential, only to an actual being. A child cannot acquire any rights until it is born. The living take precedence over the not-yet-living (or the unborn)."
"Abortion is a moral right—which should be left to the sole discretion of the woman involved; morally, nothing other than her wish in the matter is to be considered. Who can conceivably have the right to dictate to her what disposition she is to make of the functions of her own body?"
Can't wait until he finds out Aquinas wrote stuff like, "man ought to possess external things, not as his own, but as common, so that, to wit, he is ready to communicate them to others in their need"
I love the way Rachel says "Young Guuuuuns"! lol...this D@#K will be history when the Red tide washes out.....
WTH? He speaks like Sarah Palin!