
TRMS viewer Joel Meredith
Calling it "a major day in Michigan's history," Republican Gov. Rick Snyder (R) signed a brutal anti-union bill -- a so-called "right-to-work" proposal -- into law this evening, just hours after GOP lawmakers jammed the bill through the legislature's lame-duck session.
Michigan became the 24th right-to-work state in the blink of an eye Tuesday after the state House rushed through legislation and Gov. Rick Snyder immediately signed it, capping a day of charged emotions, huge crowds and mostly peaceful demonstrations.
The speed with which the controversial legislation became law left organized labor and Democrats reeling. There is talk of legal challenges and recall efforts or opponents could try to mount a drive to put a constitutional amendment on the 2014 ballot aimed at overturning right-to-work. But Democrats and labor leaders say they are mostly focused on 2014, when they hope to regain control of the Legislature and the governor's office in the face of what they see as a Republican over-reach.
Today's move comes less than a year after Snyder assured the public that he saw the anti-union proposal as "divisive" and "not appropriate in Michigan during 2012." With a stroke of a pen -- Snyder signed the bill into law behind closed doors, away from public view -- the governor broke that promise earlier this evening.
For more background on the larger issue, I'd recommend Laura Conaway's terrific Maddow Blog coverage, and the segment Rachel aired last night.





The unions need to go back to their confrontational activities so the capital parties, Democrat and Republican, take notice or become irrelevant for workers.
I cannot fathom the worldview that morally justfies actions like this. Guess that's why I'll never be rich.
It was pay back time for Snyder and the Repubs in the Michigan legislature. The Kochs came calling to receive a pay back for getting them elected in 2010. The Kochs would be happy if all unions would go away. Then they would be able to ravage the workers without anyone in the room to object. Right to work is only the first step in the Kochs' anti-union, anti-middle class campaign.
It's called freedom of choice.
Something that the GOP hates more then they hate everyone unlike them. Funny how they whine about choice while at the same time support a party that wants to take away all choices they don't agree with. Except in this case no one is forcing you to take a union job you made that decision by choosing to apply at a unionized business, that was your choice no one forced you to apply for said job. Really you righties just can't grasp word comprehension. Here is an example of no choice, being born with a disability outside of that life is full of choices so stop whining already.
NBC network news had the CNBC auto industry " expert " on , with zero labor representation for the counter balance , mr expert said all the car companies are building new plants down south ...So the message was imo , take pay cuts american workers , and get use to it
But what about the profiteers taking a profit cut? What about mr cnbc taking a pay cut for the good of the cnbc profiteers? How would they report that? How is it good for america ,when the middle class take yet another pay cut ? How about they add that too their next piece about how incomes are down ? They never connect the dots , because then people might see the solution and have faith , and demand change , can the people down south afford to buy the product they are producing ? I doubt it
Well, those non-union jobs ARE higher-wage jobs for the folks down south...The car companies are just applying outsourcing tactics without leaving the country.
I wish for Christmas what ill will we have seen was not so real and vital for Americans to fight. And again worse yet to have to speak acknowledgement of their aims; not just political, breaking unions, and syphoning the last strength of the middle class. But it is also about what it would mean for them to control the USA labor market. It's not like "they" consider themselves Americans first.
And as far as their office holder kennel hounds and duped masses......
nvm. The eve's cloudy and closing. Weather it and ready all for next heat.
C, that would be incorrect. The reason they're building them down here is that these are ALREADY RTW states, so they can make the same product and tell the workers to eat the lower wages.
After all, Look how helpful Unions have been to the auto industry in Michigan and ohio these last Twenty years...*Rolling eyes* And Let's not forget the thuggery and beatings and violence that has followed these Unions....They brought about their own demise and may they rest in peace.
Scott, this is no longer the 1950s.
Notice scottie repeats scenes he saw on movies about unions. Yet scottie ignores the thuggery of the anti union strike breakers as well as the hired thugs in local police departments hired to protect big business.
The auto industry wrecked itself, Scottie me boy, by making crap cars that resulted from bowing to pressure from big oil; after all, crappy MPG equals more sales in gasoline! People didn't buy Japanese cars because they were cooler or sportier or because they hated America; they bought them because it didn't cost them a c-note to commute.
Has anyone noticed the similarity with which the Michigan state government has pushed through the anti-union legislation to the Egyptian government under Morsi who is pushing through the vote on the new constitution which is causing large demonstrations against it?
Just saying......
Both are run by power-hungry tools who have little caring for laws except to use them to punish those they dislike; perish the thought they might be constrained by them.
Ricky you gotta lotta splainin' to do!
I do not belong to a union and never have. I have benefited from the efforts of unions - have enjoyed 40 hour work weeks, overtime, sick pay, vacation days, safe work place etc - all of that good stuff.
Perhaps what needs to happen now is a rethinking of the role of unions. Why is it that the driving force behind workers rights is left up to the unions? The rest of us that benefit have been able to just sit back and let them do the tough work. Unions have historically provided significant support for the Democrats. Again, the rest of us have not contributed as much as we should.
I am not very far from retirement, but will always be a consumer. What power does a worker have? Not much. What power does a single consumer have? Not much. The unions were a powerful mechanism to organize workers. Is it time to create a powerful mechanism to organize consumers? I KNOW that even if I pay a bit more for products and services because the workers get decent wages and benefits, I ultimately benefit and my children and grandchildren will benefit. So - how do we do this?
We do it the old fashioned way - with boycotts. During the 50's, when a TV show did something objectionable, all the viewers had to do was call the SPONSOR of the show (usually a single company like Tide detergent or Ford) and THREATEN to stop buying the product to get it off the air. Stop buying Koch Brother's industries products (I believe Georgia Pacific building materials is one, somebody will have to educate us to the rest). Do not patronize Fox News advertisers. It may take longer this time but when their revenues dry up they will too.
Many of those union-created beneifts you list are now covered by OSHA and/or the Federal Government, which makes it a duplication of effort. Your taxes pay for OSHA and the Feds, why should you HAVE to pay union dues if you don't want too?
c, those benefits were legislated to be regulated as law through government agency, and can be taken away if those of position were to stomp out those who would stop them.
@malphi, I agree. Americans have two high cards holding to build on: our work force, and our consumer purchasing power. Just a year ago, I was skeptical of our ability to educate, organize, and collectively yield our consumer purchasing power. The "Greatest Show On Earth" continues to impress me, and I have great faith.
c5499351 #6.2
Those benefits listed and more (like public education of our children instead of child labor) WOULD NOT BE LAW if unions did not FIGHT FOR THEM FIRST. Take unions away and everyone with a job will have to fight their employers and the unemployed ready to underbid them INDUVIDUALLY for the benefits and rules we take for granted here and do not exist in China, India and everywhere else companies ship factories to save labor costs. We attack unions at our peril since they are the first line of defense for workers between us and what Chinese labor lives with. I am not a union member and probably never will be, but I realize that what they have fought for over 150 years is the TRUE rising tide lifting all boats.
Will someone please ask why it is that the people that are born into money are the ones telling us how we need to live and what slackers we are? What did they ever do to earn a penny of their wealth besides screw everyone they could out of money?
That is what sends me into the stratosphere , this Snyder dude is a wall st millionaire , and he is trying to tell workers what is best for them , he represents workers thinking the same as romney does
This government move will lower wages , and he has the gull to tell workers this is about FREEING THEM? The middle class are peasants to these people , to be talked down to like we are idiots
But you talk to the poor gop white trash version of Snyder on the internet , and they agree with this clown , it is astounding to witness some times
Michigan Democrats are correct to focus on 2014. There's little they can do to change this now. The only exception to that might be a lawsuit that challenges the use of a small appropriation to avoid the possibility of citizen action to overturn it. It's very possible that a legal action could overturn that aspect of it, since the inclusion of an appropriation is done for a fraudulent purpose, and not to advance the cause of the bill itself.
Blame the republicans, Blame the buisness's Blame the Koch's Bla Blah Bleck.
Stand up, walk 4 steps, pick up the closest household item, if it says Made in China, then fricking blame yourself pal.
Blame ourselves for corporate greed that sends jobs overseas to be done in slavery conditions by people treated like machinery rather than humans for miniscule amounts of pay, while said corporations and their executives rake in huge profits and bonuses? What the f--k ever.
Corporate greed?
So you think a business should not outsource and not make a profit and have to shut down because a labor union wants too much? Economics 101. A business, no matter what size is in business to actually make a profit. The day you actually figure that out you will become a republican.
I already know it, numbnuts, but making a strawman doesn't make your argument accurate. The corporations were making fine profits, they just wanted more. They wanted more bonuses, more golden parachutes, more rewards for screwing the workers and doing nothing productive themselves. You pretend that they were on the verge of ceasing to exist, which is complete horsecrap, and you'd acknowledge that if you had a shred of honesty within you.
Also, I WAS a Republican, back in the 80s, when I was young and dumb enough to believe the lies. Conservativism, as it exists in the modern day in America, is the philosophy of the whiny baby who is crying for his blanket, or the sociopath who sees no value in other humans other than how they can profit him, or the credulous fool who buys the justification for those who exploit him.
It'll be reversed as soon as they figure out right to work, is illegal. Bye, Bye, Snyder. The GOP are just trying to ram every single ALEC bill through for money from the Koch brothers, Once the Supreme Court starts hearing cases about acts of fraud and blackmail in the state of Michigan. Wisconsin is next.The American worker comes before any get rich quick scheme.
RTW must not be illegal. Several states have it and there have been no successful challenges. The states that are growing and prospering are RTW states and have lower taxation. Some of the other states (CA as an example) are seeing an exodus.
Angel#77---- Hypocrisy at its finest. You want your right for abortion. You want your rights for free Obamanite phone, you want your rights for Gay Marriage. You want your rights for more gun control. But you don't want the right to work. Can you explain your true reasoning ???????
As many Companies as these Unions have single handedly killed with their overwhelming greed and strong arm attitudes have lost them ANY sympathy from the American worker...A little too late to become "Sensible" now.
Scott, I'll say again. This is no longer the 1950s. And we're tired of the extreme right's inability to grow up and get past that era.
You do have a right to work the righties problem is they don't want to pay for benefits they get from union job. So once again we see first hand in what I been saying all along...................righties prove they always have their hand out for free stuff then whine they didn't get enough.
Bronzestar...sorry again about that. Right to work wasn't voted on, but only the minority gets to vote on it. It works if you want your State to have the highest skilled workers being payed the minimum wage , for only part=time work. They take away contributing to your 401 first, then they stop the retirement plan altogether, no more retirement funds or pensions. Health Insurance cost you now 4 times as much as it did in 2001. No dental. You end up paying more for your insurance then it would to just go and see the Doctor without insurance and pay for it yourself. It's a scam that the medical field and the insurance field have cooked up a long time ago. Why do we need these middle men again. You can't really insure anybody that they're going to be healthy, then why should we pay for it. Same with life insurance, who cares your dead. send Wall St. the bill. A backwards mortgage another scam....weeeeee! they now own your house, and your paying rent again?? What the......Yup, they sure must think we just fell off the turnip truck. They don't care about you and me, so, we need to take care of ourselves. The one thing you can do to really piss them off is to get healthy and stay healthy.We just need to find the right Doctors who are there for service to the American citizens, not the kind that asks for your insurance information first.Or ones that act like they're doing us a favor.
Please someone Please answer this for me. If Governor Snyder now feels SOOOO strongly about this for "all" the workers in his state, why then are Policemen and Firefighters not included in this? If this is all about "Choice" and "Freedom" why do they get special treatment? I will add my 2 cents worth: Gov. Snyder saw what happened in Wisconsin and did not want those Unions going against him. Please Rachel could you address this on your show?
I wish I was special, but I'm a creep, I'm a weirdo. What the hell am I doing here, I don't belong here. Everyone is special and deserves to be treated as such.
When I'm not being a suffragette, I'm playing heavy metal music. Enjoy!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=htMjYUQ3u5Q