
Associated Press
Those who tuned in to last night's Super Bowl will probably remember two things. One was a game that looked like it was over, before becoming surprisingly competitive. And the other was the roughly half-hour in which much of the power in New Orleans' Superdome went out.
It was a rather embarrassing moment for the city in the national spotlight, but given the larger policy discussion about energy and smart grids, it was hard not to wonder if incidents like these could be avoided if the United States invested more in infrastructure.
In fact, Michael Greenwald reminded us earlier of a report from 2011 on a similar incident that nearly happened in Miami, but didn't.
In January [2011], for example, millions of Americans watched Stanford's football team win the Orange Bowl. None of them knew that an aging transformer nearly overloaded while feeding power to the stadium, triggering voltage alerts that gave new meaning to the phrase red zone. Thanks to high-tech equipment installed through a $200 million smart-grid grant to Florida Power & Light, transformers that used to be checked manually once a year were being monitored electronically every second. The new equipment detected the problem and diverted power elsewhere.
"It would've been embarrassing if the stadium had gone dark," says Bob Triana, the operations manager for FPL's Energy Smart Florida project. "I mean, it might not have gotten to that point. But I'm glad we didn't find out."
In fairness, I should note that we don't yet know enough about what happened in New Orleans to say for sure whether smart-grid technology might have prevented the Super Bowl fiasco last night.
But as Brad Plumer explained, we do know that smart grids can prevent blackouts: "And that's no small thing. Blackouts, after all, have become frustratingly common across the country. Between 2005 and 2009, there were 349 power outages in the United States that affected at least 50,000 people. That's up from just 149 outages between 2000 and 2004, according to Massoud Amin of the University of Minnesota. Problems with the power grid now cost the economy some $150 billion per year."
So, why aren't we making these kinds of investments? I'll give you one guess.
When it comes to the politics of energy policy, the problem is not that smart grids lack high-profile backing. On the contrary, President Obama is a huge fan -- he sees investments like these as good for energy, energy efficiency, energy innovation, and economic growth.
The problem, of course, is that these investments are expensive, and congressional Republicans have come to believe public investments are ... bad. If the private sector wants to invest in smart grids, that's fine, the argument goes, but GOP policymakers insist it's more important to shrink government than invest in energy infrastructure. Indeed, throughout 2010, Tea Partiers would often look at smart grids as an example of "big government" interfering with the energy sector in unnecessary ways.
Of course, the private sector has no incentive to make such investments on its own, since the costs are high, and the return on investment comes slowly over time. As a practical matter, the reality is unavoidable: either the government does it, or it doesn't happen.
To be sure, as the Miami example helps demonstrate, some progress has already happened. But as last night helped remind us, the nation has a very long way to go.





Why do Republicans hate football?
So much for austerity.
PS: I watched on TV. I found the game a lot more exciting than the black-out. Then again, I wasn't seated on the dark side of the field. God only knows what was going on over there.
The blackout is the only thing on last night's TV that I regret not seeing.
I've watched enough superhero movies that I'd anticipate an immense voice booming out:
ATTENTION, PUNY EARTHLINGS ...
Ironically, they'll offer all sorts of tax incentives to get a stadium built. But maintained? Screw that, that's Someone Else's Problem.
It's all government interference till the power goes down long enough for the deep freeze to thaw, then it's why didn't the government do something? Since Gig Gov wants to butt into everything it's all so obvious this is something they need to butt into .... now.
In other words, Infrastructure won the Super Bowl!
A friend commented that "the guys in Vegas sent the signal and the Ravens were supposed to go down in the 4th quarter".. Lolz
Someone is going to have to bring it up : Why are we tolerating the Republican war against the country?
Their problem with reality can be considered "personal" but the impact on the rest of us isn't.
I highly recommend the NFL have Motel 6 host the next Super Bowl. Done! :)
"We'll leave the light on for you®"
In ancient Rome they appeased the masses by staging circuses and gave away free bread.
In modern America we reduce taxes.
Smart grids are a great idea---except that they are vulnerable to hackers. We just had an instance where Equifax lost a lot of confidential data, and the NY Times was attacked by Chinese hackers for months on end. Our cybersecurity always seems to be a step or two behind hackers. Unless we can prove that we have the security to keep a smart grid safe from hackers, I don't see it as a great thing right now.
Looks to me like they are blaming the smart grid.
"A statement from Entergy and the Superdome said Sunday that a piece of equipment monitoring electrical load sensed the abnormality and opened a breaker, partially cutting power."
FWIW, dumb relays (manually set) can also sense abnormalities and trip the breaker. Old schooling it.
It would be nice if, instead of simply supporting something, Obama and Democrats actually went about the difficult task of educating about and fighting for the things they supposedly believe in.
Everyone helped build the infrastructure. Everyone can help maintain it.
A timely article today "Corpocrisy: The Systematic Betrayal of American Workers" by Paul Buchheit http://www.nationofchange.org/print/36179 highlighting what "we the people" have given and what the corporations have received.
Is this the same place that starred in a major natural disaster and needed whole bunches of homemade electricity to keep people, you know, like alive? Last nite's minor glitch served as a dress rehearsal for the backup equipment it will need in case NOLA ever has another MND. Assuming, of course, that climate change isn't a Democrat myth.
How come Wayne LaPierre hasn't yammered about the crime wave in the darkened stands because of the failure of the attendees to be packing?
Obviously, it was the Illuminati.
I thought it was Ron Weasley playing with Dumbledore's deluminator. Now he has to hear Hermione saying "I told you to leave it at home!" every time it's brought up.
If it were The Illuminati, wouldn't it have been illuminated instead of a blackout?
There was a similar event at the Manchester United - Fulham match the previous day in light of the numerous high profile hacking events does anyone think theres some link to the two blackout events--not much of a conspiracy theorist normally